The Butter Baby is a rich and indulgent blended cocktail that combines vanilla ice cream, milk, vodka, and butterscotch schnapps for a dessert-like treat. Creamy, smooth, and sweet, it bridges the line between a milkshake and an adult after-dinner drink.
Blend vanilla ice cream, milk, vodka, and butterscotch schnapps until smooth and velvety. Pour into a chilled beer mug. Garnish with fresh blueberries and a drizzle of caramel sauce.
Served in a large beer mug, topped with blueberries and a generous caramel drizzle for a decadent milkshake-inspired finish.
Excellent with caramel flan, pecan pie, buttery cookies, or any dessert featuring warm caramel notes.
A contemporary creation born from late 20th–21st century dessert cocktail trends, merging ice cream treats with spirits.
Perfect for dessert service, cozy nights in, or any moment when a sweet, blended indulgence is in order.
Velvety and smooth, with creamy vanilla sweetness, buttery caramel undertones, and a subtle warmth from vodka and schnapps.
Playful, comforting, indulgent — a grown-up milkshake with a luxurious twist.
Add chocolate liqueur for a mocha effect, or swap milk with almond milk for a lighter, nutty profile.
5%
⚠️ Alcoholic beverage: not suitable for minors, pregnant individuals, or designated drivers. Please enjoy responsibly.
Start from the ingredient that shapes this recipe before moving into broader style, method or glassware lists.
Drinks where Vanilla Ice Cream shapes the recipe structure.
Same ingredient prepared with the same method.
Same ingredient served in the same glassware family.
Follow the same category, preparation method or glassware logic to compare drinks that behave like Butter Baby in a specific way.
These routes use ingredient pairs that actually appear in Butter Baby and group cocktails with the same pairing logic.
Cocktails where Vanilla Ice Cream and Milk appear together in the recipe structure.
Butter Baby sits around 5% ABV. Use these routes to compare drinks with a similar drinking weight, then narrow them by style, method or glass.
Cocktails served in Beer Mug glass within 0–5% ABV.
Next paths
Choose the next route by style, method, glass or ingredient.
Browse all recipes A–Z
See more from this style
Explore cocktails built the same way
Find serves in this glass
Explore drinks where Vanilla Ice Cream shapes the recipe.
Learn the spirits, liqueurs, and mixers in our index
